[Technical Sharing] “Builders” in the Dishwasher and Fabric Detergent Industries

Builders In the dishwashing and fabric‑washing industries, “builders” almost exclusively refer to ingredients that remove hardness ions such as Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ from the wash solution, providing chelating and dispersing effects. Removing these ions is crucial for eliminating most soils and stains. Under high‑pH washing conditions, hydrolyzed starches (pK ≈ 12) and polyphenols (pKa ≈ 10) in tea can be bridged by calcium ions to negatively charged glass or ceramic surfaces, while protein soils may bridge to stainless steel surfaces. In such cases, maintaining pCa > 4 (where pCa = −log[Ca²⁺], meaning [Ca²⁺] < 10⁻⁴ mol/L) is essential to displace these bridging ions. Calcium ions can also adversely affect the appearance of glass by enhancing adsorption of protein soils. Low levels of hardness ions further promote thorough cleaning by reducing the likelihood of precipitates formed from saponified fats or dissolved CO₂, thereby mitigating issues related to scale buildup. Another key function of builders targets soils composed of calcium or magnesium salts—extracting these hardness ions is the most effective way to remove them. A prime example is stubborn tea stains. Strong chelating agents such as phosphates or EDTA (which can raise pCa to ≥6) are used to extract calcium salts from tea stains. In principle, dishwasher detergent formulations can select builders from three main categories: precipitants like sodium carbonate or potassium oleate; ion‑exchange agents such as zeolites; and chelating agents including phosphates, citrates, and polycarboxylates. Chelating agents constitute the largest group and are most commonly employed in dishwasher detergents because they remain in solution, leaving no residues on glassware. The choice of builder also depends on the system’s pH. Traditionally, phosphates have been favored at higher pH values, where their chelating efficacy is strongest. This category includes sodium tripolyphosphate (STPP, Na₅P₃O₁₀), tetrasodium pyrophosphate (TSPP, Na₄P₂O₇), tetrapotassium pyrophosphate (TKPP)—with potassium salts exhibiting higher solubility than sodium salts, making them advantageous in liquid formulations—and sodium tetrapolyphosphate (STMP, Na₄P₄O₇). Weaker chelating agents are not without drawbacks. For instance, polycarboxylates exhibit what is known as the polyelectrolyte effect: their complexation capacity (CCC) increases with polymer molecular weight up to around 10,000. Here, the charge density of the polymer backbone becomes paramount. Taking BASF’s Sokalan CP‑7 as an example, it requires a high content of maleic acid (cis‑butenedioic acid) or a 50/50 acrylic/maleic copolymer with a molecular weight of approximately 50,000, whose complexation constant is roughly ten times that of comparable polyacrylates. However, polycarboxylates like CP‑7 interact strongly with calcium ions and tend to precipitate under high‑hardness conditions, leading to a glassy surface appearance. Moreover, even the highest‑binding polycarboxylates fall short compared to precipitant‑type builders such as carbonates. Consequently, in water with high carbonate hardness, calcium carbonate forms before calcium ions can bind to the polymer. Fortunately, polycarboxylates serve as effective inhibitors of crystal growth, preventing deposits on tableware. Yet, low polymer molecular weights favor inhibition of crystal growth, whereas robust chelation requires high molecular weights—implying a distinct bimodal distribution of chain lengths. Long chains are necessary for effective chelation, which introduces another drawback of polyacrylates: biodegradability. When polymers reach a length sufficient to exert chelating action, the most efficient acrylic and maleic monomers become non‑biodegradable. Attempts to construct block copolymers using biodegradable comonomers such as vinyl alcohol often result in polymers either containing excessive vinyl alcohol, rendering them unable to chelate effectively, or excessively rich in acrylic/maleic components, compromising biodegradability. For these reasons, polycarboxylates are typically used in dishwasher detergents as co‑builders or simply as scale inhibitors. In phosphate‑free systems, when the wash solution’s pH drops, the preferred builder today is trisodium citrate, whose masking capability remains insensitive to pH changes. Citrate is a safe, biodegradable agent derived from sugar fermentation. Its main drawbacks are its relatively high cost and moderate masking performance. Furthermore, the weaker masking provided by citrate necessitates the inclusion of an effective bleaching agent to prevent the accumulation of tea stains.

22

2021

/

11

Common components of dishwasher detergent formulations

Based on their roles in detergents, these components are categorized as follows: buffers, builders, scale inhibitors, bleaching agents, enzymes, spot/film control agents, and antifoams. Beyond their individual forms and functions, these components interact with and depend upon one another. Buffers Buffers are used to increase the alkalinity of detergent solutions; it is well known that high-pH formulations generally offer superior performance in removing soil. In an earlier review, a formulation with a pH of 11.1 was compared to one with a pH of 9.8. The lower-pH formulation performed less effectively against laboratory soils composed of cooked egg, cereal, milk, and margarine. It has been demonstrated that higher detergent pH levels significantly enhance the swelling of soils, thereby facilitating their removal. For example, studies examining pre-cooked starch gels at 50°C revealed that their swelling rate in alkaline buffer solutions increased progressively as the buffer pH rose from 8 to 12. This effect also applies to protein hydrolysis and subsequent removal of egg-based soils. At elevated pH values, both types of soils become partially ionized, and the repulsive forces between like-charged groups within the soil greatly reduce its cohesive strength. Additionally, since glass and ceramic substrates carry negative charges at high pH, the adhesion of soils to these surfaces is further diminished. Tea stains, particularly when accumulated, also pose fewer problems at higher pH levels, as the polyphenolic chromophores in tea are believed to undergo deprotonation, thereby reducing soil adhesion and cohesion. On the downside, highly alkaline pH can lead to damage to certain materials, such as discoloration. Effective buffers commonly used in dishwashing detergents include sodium hydroxide, sodium carbonate, and various silicates. For some silicates, 1% aqueous solutions exhibit pH values of 13.1, 11.4, and 12.3 at 20°C. Phosphates, primarily employed as builders, also contribute modest buffering capacity. Although baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) tends to form water films, its affordability and widespread availability ensure its continued use in dishwashing detergents. Carbonates, silicates, other alkaline reagents, and their mixtures provide multiple avenues for raising the pH of detergent solutions. A pH range of 11–12 is favorable for cleaning; however, recent advances in the field of machine dishwashing have largely aimed at lowering detergent pH levels to minimize environmental impact and reduce human exposure risks. Ideally, while maintaining compatibility with enzyme stability, bleach efficacy, and health and environmental considerations, selecting the highest feasible pH value—maximizing the benefits of alkaline mechanisms—can bring detergent pH down to around 10. Within this range, deprotonation of soils still offers some advantages for removing egg-based (proteinaceous) soils, though most soil removal relies on enzymatic action. Nevertheless, even a reduction of about one pH unit has proven costly when attempting to remove stubborn tea stains. A decline in the degree of soil deprotonation implies that extremely low free calcium ion concentrations are required to maintain low soil cohesion and adhesion. Calcium‑chelating agents are essentially acids that lose effectiveness at lower pH levels; thus, when formulating at reduced pH values, formulators must balance several conflicting trends. For dishwashing detergents, the reserve alkalinity of phosphates, silicates, and sodium hydroxide exceeds 6.2%. Among them, alkaline silicates serve as critical alkaline buffers in dishwashing formulations, including highly corrosive sodium metasilicate (Na₂SiO₃·nH₂O).

19

2021

/

11

[Standard Introduction] Standards and Specifications Related to Dishwasher Detergents

Currently, China lacks a national product standard for dishwasher detergents; manufacturers rely on self‑established enterprise standards to ensure product quality. The detergency of dishwasher detergents can be evaluated by referring to GB/T 24692‑2009 “Surfactants—Guidelines for Comparative Testing of Detergent Performance for Household Machine Dishwashing” and GB/T 20290‑2016 “Test Methods for the Performance of Household Electric Dishwashers.” For assessing the wash‑resistance of ceramic tableware, SN/T 3535‑2013 “Test Method for Wash‑Resistance of Daily‑Use Ceramics in Dishwashers” is applicable. Internationally, there are recommendations from IKW (B part, updated in 2015) for evaluating the cleaning performance of dishwasher detergents, as well as ASTM D3556‑2014, which measures the performance of mechanical dishwashing detergents on glassware. In 2010, the American Home Appliance Manufacturers Association (AHAM) established the standard ANSI/AHAM DW‑1‑2010 for household electric dishwashers, specifying procedures for testing their cleaning performance. Additionally, the European Union and New Zealand have issued relevant regulations for dishwasher detergents under eco‑labeling schemes. GB/T 24692‑2009 “Surfactants—Guidelines for Comparative Testing of Detergent Performance for Household Machine Dishwashing” was adopted with modifications based on ISO 7535:1984 “Surfactants—Guidelines for Comparative Testing of Detergent Performance for Household Machine Dishwashing” (English version). To conduct comparative tests of various household machine dishwashing detergents and rinse aids, it is necessary to consider both relevant and seemingly irrelevant variables, along with their specific importance. These factors vary across countries and regions, depending on: - The diversity of soil caused by different dietary habits; - The materials used in manufacturing kitchen utensils, tableware, and cutlery; - Water quality and limitations in selecting suitable dishes for machine washing; - The operating programs of dishwashers. Given the widespread use of domestic dishwashers abroad—even though they are not yet commonly used in China—this product already has a market presence here. Moreover, international standards exist that mandate comparative testing of dishwasher detergent performance. Therefore, it is essential to establish guidelines tailored to China’s national conditions for conducting comparative tests of household machine dishwashing detergents and rinse aids. Recognizing that comparative test data derived from similar basic testing methods are important and valuable to users, this standard specifies criteria that must be considered when designing experiments and interpreting results. The primary criterion affecting all consumers is the effective removal of various types of soil from household utensils contaminated by food and beverages, while minimizing damage to both the utensils and the washing equipment. Another criterion is the appearance of clean utensils, such as the absence of stains or film residues. Although toxicity and ecological considerations are extremely important for products widely used in households, these fall outside the scope of this standard and are therefore not addressed herein. This standard outlines the principles that should guide the design of optimal comparative tests for different types of dishwashers, as well as how to develop satisfactory comparative testing methods. Furthermore, this standard provides guidelines for establishing methods and evaluation procedures for comparing the performance of household machine dishwashing detergents. It applies to solid (including paste-like) or liquid detergents and rinse aids formulated from surfactants and auxiliary ingredients, intended for use in household dishwashers. Terms and Definitions The following terms and definitions apply to this standard: Household Machine Dishwashing Detergent: A detergent specially formulated for use in household dishwashers. Household Machine Dishwashing Rinse Aid: A liquid (preferably added during rinsing) or solid (added during continuous washing and left in the dishwasher) product designed to enhance the appearance and drying effect of utensils washed in household dishwashers. 3.1 Detergent Detergents selected for performance testing should be within their shelf life. If comparing certain physical characteristics among different detergent samples—such as uniformity, density, solubility, dispersibility, etc.—tests should be conducted using undamaged packaging, samples within their shelf life, and stored under identical conditions. 3.2 Load of Soiled Utensils 3.2.1 Soil Tests are best conducted using utensils normally soiled in homes or small eateries. Each repeated test should employ utensils of similar size and composition. Due to the diversity of utensils and soils, multiple repetitions are required for each type of utensil to obtain statistically significant results. The duration of soil exposure should not exceed one day. The nature of the soil and storage conditions—such as relative humidity and temperature—must be carefully controlled. Possible soil types include: oils and fats, proteins, carbohydrates, residual food particles, tea, coffee, tannins from wine, lipstick, fruit stains, and burnt or baked food residues. Normal everyday soil can be simulated in the laboratory by applying commonly used foods onto tableware. Appendix B of this standard uses domestically common foods, mixed in specific proportions to create various soil types, which are quantitatively applied to tableware for simulation tests. 3.2.2 Single Washing vs. Multiple Washings For previously used utensils, if thoroughly cleaned before reuse and their surfaces or protective layers remain undamaged, they may undergo a single washing assessment. The single-washing method does not reflect cumulative effects but only partially indicates the detergent’s washing performance. To evaluate cumulative effects—such as metal losing its luster, forming stains (e.g., from coffee or tea), or impacting glaze—the repeated-washing method should be employed, wherein the test utensils are repeatedly subjected to cycles of soiling, washing, and storage. 3.2.3 Unsoiled Utensils Unsoiled utensils can be used to assess re‑deposition of soil or potential damage. When conducting such evaluations, repeated washings should be performed even in the presence of a soil load. It should be noted that re‑deposition of soil is usually influenced primarily by the dishwasher itself rather than by the detergent used. 3.2.4 Types and Materials of Utensils Utensils—including tableware, cutlery, and kitchenware—may be made from porcelain, glass, ceramics, metals, plastics, polytetrafluoroethylene, and other materials. Porous materials and wood should be avoided. 3.2.5 Loading Capacity Follow the instructions provided by the dishwasher manufacturer. 3.3 Washing Process The washing process is constrained by the selected dishwasher. This test recommends using one of the currently prevalent domestic models for experimentation. 3.3.1 Dishwasher 3.3.1.1 Installation Install the dishwasher according to the manufacturer’s instructions. 3.3.1.2 Water When using a dishwasher equipped with an internal water softener, regular tap water generally suffices. If a water softener is available, regeneration should follow the manufacturer’s guidelines. In the absence of an internal water softener, if testing only one water hardness level, the average domestic water hardness may be chosen. Ideally, three water hardness levels should be tested: below, equal to, and above the national average. If artificially prepared hard water is used, the ratio of calcium and magnesium ions must be specified. 3.3.1.3 Number of Dishwashers Typically, one unit is used. For comparative purposes, it is preferable to operate two identical dishwashers simultaneously. When comparing several dishwashers at once, they should be of the same model, and their accurate operation during pre‑test and test phases must be verified. 3.3.2 Loading Method Each utensil’s position should follow the manufacturer’s instructions. During testing, precise placement of every utensil must be ensured: knives, forks, and tableware should be arranged separately in designated compartments of the basket. Different metal items must not be mixed in the same compartment, nor should they come into contact with adjacent metal pieces. Each utensil’s positioning should adhere to the manufacturer’s specifications. Under all circumstances, soiled surfaces must be placed according to the prescribed instructions. 3.3.3 Cycle The standard washing program of the dishwasher serves as one cycle, comprising washing, rinsing, and drying. Time and temperature parameters should remain constant within the range specified by the dishwasher. During repeated washings, utensils must be dried between cycles and cooled to room temperature beforehand. 3.3.4 Addition of Detergent Add a specified amount of detergent before each test, as recommended by the detergent manufacturer. If no specific quantity is indicated, the amount suggested in the dishwasher manufacturer’s instructions may be used. 3.3.5 Addition of Rinse Aid During dishwashing, both detergent and rinse aid are often used. When comparing detergents, whether or not to add a rinse aid depends on the requirements of that particular product. Conversely, when comparing rinse aids, they must always be used together with detergent. 3.4 Performance Characteristics 3.4.1 Overview A single assessment cannot predict the overall performance of a dishwasher detergent; a series of evaluations is required to examine various aspects and provide a qualitative judgment of total performance. 3.4.2 Classification of Performance Characteristics The overall performance of a detergent can be categorized according to several independent criteria, including: 3.4.2.1 Final Appearance of Dishes This item involves examining the following aspects: - Removal of soil; - Elimination of stains; - Clearance of dry or charred cooking residues; - Presence or absence of stains and film residues; - Re‑deposition. To obtain a clear picture of effective soil removal and re‑deposition effects, multiple repeated tests are necessary. 3.4.2.2 Drying Efficiency This item is influenced by the dishwasher’s operation, water temperature, the composition and shape of utensils, their placement within the machine, and the use of rinse aids. It also allows for comparison of the impact of rinse aids on draining, drying, and final appearance. 3.4.2.3 Resistance to Damage During Washing This item encompasses chemical and physical damage, including impacts on protective layer color, loss of metallic luster, and changes in optical properties of glass surfaces. Generally, tests assessing the loss of luster in aluminum products can be evaluated after five to ten washes. Fading of protective layer colors may require hundreds of tests. To enable rapid evaluation of protective layer discoloration, accelerated testing methods outlined in Appendix C may be employed. Note: As these are accelerated tests, results obtained through Appendix C methods may sometimes differ from actual outcomes. Since other factors can also cause damage, physical and chemical damage should be distinguished. 3.4.2.4 Impact on Washing Equipment This item includes any interactions between the detergent and the washing machine.Corrosion in dishwashers is of great concern to consumers; assessing this effect requires new dishwashers or components.

06

2021

/

11