[Standard Introduction] Standards and Specifications Related to Dishwasher Detergents
Nov 06,2021
At present, China lacks a national product standard for dishwasher detergents; manufacturers therefore rely on self‑established enterprise standards to ensure product quality. The detergency of dishwasher detergents can be assessed in accordance with GB/T 24692‑2009 “Surfactants—Guidelines for Comparative Testing of Household Dishwasher Detergent Performance” and GB/T 20290‑2016 “Test Methods for the Performance of Domestic Electric Dishwashers.” For evaluating the wash‑resistance of ceramic tableware, SN/T 3535‑2013 “Test Method for Wash‑Resistance of Daily‑Use Ceramics in Dishwashers” is applicable. Internationally, there are recommendations from IKW for assessing the cleaning performance of dishwasher detergents (Part B, updated in 2015), as well as ASTM D3556‑2014, which specifies methods for measuring the performance of mechanical dishwashing detergents on glassware. In 2010, the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM) in the United States issued the standard ANSI/AHAM DW‑1‑2010 for domestic electric dishwashers, outlining procedures for testing the cleaning efficacy of household dishwashers. Meanwhile, the European Union and New Zealand have promulgated relevant regulations governing dishwasher detergents in the context of eco‑labeling schemes.
GB/T 24692-2009, “Surfactants — Guidelines for Comparative Testing of the Performance of Household Dishwashing Detergents for Machine Washing,” is a standard that adopts, with modifications, ISO 7535:1984, “Surfactants — Guidelines for Comparative Testing of the Performance of Household Dishwashing Detergents for Machine Washing” (English version).
To conduct comparative tests on the performance of various household dishwashing detergents and rinse aids, it is necessary to consider both relevant and seemingly irrelevant variables, as well as specific factors and their relative importance. These factors vary across countries and regions, depending on:
— Due to varying dietary habits, there is a diversity of dental plaque.
— Materials used in the manufacture of kitchenware, tableware, and cutlery;
— Water quality and the limitations of machine-washable tableware options;
— The dishwasher’s cycle.
Given the widespread adoption of household dishwashers abroad, even though they have not yet become commonplace in China, it is nonetheless necessary to establish guidelines for performance‑comparison testing of detergents and rinse aids intended for use in domestic dishwashers. This is because such products are already available in the Chinese market, and relevant international standards already stipulate requirements for comparative tests of dishwasher detergent performance.
Given that comparative test data obtained using similar basic test methods are important and valuable to users, this standard specifies the criteria that must be considered when designing tests and evaluating results. The primary criterion affecting all consumers is the effective removal of various types of soiling from household utensils contaminated by food and beverages, while minimizing damage to both the utensils and the washing equipment. Another criterion is the appearance of clean utensils, such as the absence of stains and film residues.
Although toxicity and ecological properties are of paramount importance for products widely used in households, they fall outside the scope of this standard and are therefore not specified.
This standard specifies the principles that should be followed when designing optimal comparative tests for different types of dishwashers, as well as the methods for developing satisfactory comparative test procedures.
This standard specifies the methods for conducting comparative performance tests and the guidelines for evaluating household dishwashing detergents intended for machine use.
This standard applies to the determination of the performance of solid (including paste‑like) or liquid dishwashing detergents and rinse aids formulated from surfactants, auxiliaries, and other raw materials.
Terms and Definitions
The following terms and definitions apply to this standard.
Detergents for domestic machine dishwashing are specially formulated for use in household dishwashers.
Wash lotion for domestic machine dishwashing
A liquid (best added during the rinse cycle) or solid (added during continuous cycles and left in the dishwasher) product specially formulated to enhance the appearance of dishes and improve drying performance in household dishwashers.
3. 1 Detergent
Detergents should be selected from those within their shelf life for performance testing.
If it is necessary to compare certain physical properties—such as uniformity, density, solubility, and dispersibility—among different detergent samples, the tests should be conducted using samples that are undamaged, within their shelf life, and stored under identical conditions.
3.2 Load of Contaminated Equipment
3.2. 1 Dirt
It is preferable to use utensils that are normally contaminated in households or small eateries for the experiments. Each replicate should employ contamination‑laden utensils of similar size and composition. Moreover, given the diversity of utensils and types of soil, multiple replicates are required for each experimental setup to yield statistically significant results. The duration of contaminant exposure should not exceed one day. The nature of the contaminants and the storage conditions—such as relative humidity and temperature—should be carefully controlled.
Selectable stains include: oils and fats, proteins, carbohydrates, food‑related soil, tea, coffee, tannins from wine, lipstick, fruit stains, as well as burnt and baked food residues.
Contamination encountered under normal use can be simulated in the laboratory by applying commonly used food‑borne contaminants to tableware. Appendix B of this standard employs domestically prevalent foods, which are formulated into various types of stains according to specified ratios and applied quantitatively to tableware for simulation testing.
3.2.2 Single Wash and Multiple Washes
For previously used test articles, provided they have been thoroughly cleaned prior to reuse and their surfaces or protective coatings remain undamaged, a single‑wash evaluation may be conducted. By definition, the single‑wash method does not account for cumulative effects; it only partially reflects the product’s wash performance.
To evaluate cumulative effects—such as loss of metallic luster, the formation of stains (e.g., from coffee or tea), and their impact on the glaze surface—the repeated‑washing method should be employed. This involves subjecting the test articles to cycles of soiling, washing, and storage, with these steps repeated multiple times.
3. 2.3 Uncontaminated Utensils
Uncontaminated utensils may be used to assess soil redeposition or damage. When conducting such an evaluation, repeated washing must be performed in the presence of a contaminant load.
It should be noted that redeposition of soil is typically influenced primarily by the dishwasher itself, rather than by the detergent used.
3.2.4 Types of Equipment and Materials of Construction
This includes tableware, cutlery, and kitchen utensils, which may be made from materials such as porcelain, glass, earthenware, metal, plastic, or polytetrafluoroethylene. Porous boards and wood should not be used.
3.2.5 Loading Capacity
Follow the dishwasher manufacturer’s instructions.
3.3 Washing Process |
The washing process is constrained by the type of dishwasher selected. This study recommends using a commonly available domestic dishwasher for testing.
3.3. 1 Dishwasher
3. 3. 1. 1 Installation
Install the dishwasher according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
3.3. 1.2 Water
When using a dishwasher equipped with an internal water softener, ordinary tap water is usually sufficient. If a water softening agent is installed, it should be regenerated according to the dishwasher manufacturer’s instructions.
When no domestic water softener is installed, if only one water hardness level is being tested, the average domestic water hardness may be used. Ideally, three water hardness levels should be employed: below, equal to, and above the average domestic water hardness.
If artificially prepared hard water is used, the ratio of calcium to magnesium ions should be specified.
3.3. 1.3 Number of Dishwashers
Typically, one unit is used. When conducting a comparative test, it is best to use two identical dishwashers simultaneously.
For comparison purposes, when several dishwashers are operated simultaneously, they should be of the same model; furthermore, their accurate operation throughout all stages of the test must be verified both prior to and during the experiment.
3.3.2 Loading Method
Position of each utensil: Load according to the manufacturer’s instructions. During testing, the precise location of each utensil must be specified; knives, forks, and other tableware should be placed in separate compartments of the basket. Different metal items must not be mixed in the same compartment, nor may they come into contact with metal items in adjacent compartments.
Positioning of each item: Follow the dishwasher manufacturer’s instructions for placement. Under all circumstances, contaminated surfaces must be positioned in accordance with the instructions.
3.3.3 Periodicity
The standard wash cycle of the dishwasher is used as a single cycle, comprising washing, rinsing, and drying. The set time and temperature parameters must be maintained. Water pressure should remain constant within the range specified by the dishwasher.
When performing repeated washings, the apparatus shall be dried between each cycle and pre-cooled to room temperature.
3.3.4 Addition of Detergent
Add a specified amount of detergent before each test, as recommended by the detergent manufacturer. If no dosage is specified, use the amount suggested in the dishwasher manufacturer’s instructions.
3.3.5 Addition of the Rinse Agent
During dishwashing, two types of products are commonly used: detergent and rinse aid. When comparing detergents, whether or not to use a rinse aid should be determined according to the product’s instructions. Conversely, when evaluating rinse aids, they must always be used in conjunction with a detergent.
3.4 Performance Characteristics
3.4.1 Overview
A single evaluation cannot predict the overall performance of a dishwashing detergent for machine use; a series of assessments is required to evaluate various aspects and provide a qualitative judgment of its total performance.
3.4.2 Classification of Performance Characteristics
The overall performance of detergents can be classified according to several independent criteria, including:
3.4.2. Final Appearance of the Plate
This project includes an examination of the following items:
Removal of dirt;
— Removal of stains;
— Removal of dried or charred cooking residues;
— Presence or absence of stains and film marks;
—Redeposition.
To obtain a clear picture of the effective removal and redeposition of fouling, several replicate experiments are required.
3. 4. 2. 2 Drying Efficiency
This process is influenced by the dishwasher’s operation, water temperature, the composition and shape of the utensils, their placement within the dishwasher, and the use of rinse aids. It also allows for comparing the effects of rinse aids on draining, drying, and appearance.
3. 4. 2. 3 Durability of utensils during the washing process
This project encompasses both chemical and physical degradation, including effects on the color of protective coatings, loss of metallic luster, and changes in the optical properties of glass surfaces.
In general, for tests assessing the loss of luster in aluminum products, evaluation is typically conducted after 5 to 10 wash cycles. However, fading of the protective coating may require several hundred cycles. To evaluate such fading within a shorter timeframe, an accelerated test procedure as specified in Appendix C may also be employed.
Note: As this is an accelerated test, in certain cases, the results obtained using the method specified in Appendix C may differ from those observed under actual conditions.
Since other factors can also cause injury, it is important to distinguish between physical and chemical injuries.
3. 4. 2. 4 Impact on Washing Equipment
This project encompasses any interactions between the product and the washing machine.
Corrosion in dishwashers is of great concern to consumers; assessing this effect requires new dishwashers or components.