[Technical Sharing] “Builders” in the Dishwasher and Fabric Detergent Industries
Nov 22,2021
Builder (auxiliary agent)
In both the dishwashing and fabric‑washing sectors, the term “builder” almost exclusively refers to ingredients that remove hardness ions such as Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ from the wash solution, exerting chelating and dispersing effects. Eliminating these ions is essential for removing most soils and stains. Under high‑pH washing conditions, hydrolyzed starches (pK ≈ 12) and polyphenols (pKa ≈ 10) in tea can be bridged by calcium ions to negatively charged glass or ceramic surfaces, while protein soils may bridge to stainless steel surfaces. In such scenarios, maintaining a pCa greater than 4—where pCa = −log[Ca²⁺], meaning [Ca²⁺] < 10⁻⁴ mol/L—is critical to displace these bridging ions. Calcium ions can also adversely affect the appearance of glass, likely by enhancing the adsorption of protein soils. Low levels of hardness ions further promote thorough cleaning by reducing the likelihood of precipitates formed from saponified fats or dissolved CO₂. In this way, the formation of scale deposits can be minimized.
Another important function of builders is directed at scale composed of calcium or magnesium salts—extracting the hardness ions from such deposits is the most effective way to remove them. A prime example of this type of soil is stubborn tea stains. Strong chelating agents like phosphates or EDTA (which can achieve a pCa of 6 or higher) can be used to extract the calcium‑salt components from these stains. In principle, builders for dishwashing detergent formulations can be selected from three distinct categories: precipitants such as sodium carbonate or potassium oleate; ion‑exchange agents like zeolites; and chelating agents such as phosphates, citrates, and polycarboxylates. Chelating agents constitute the largest class of builders and are the most widely used in dishwashing detergents because they remain in solution and therefore do not leave residues on glassware.
The choice of additives also depends on the pH of the system. Traditionally, phosphates are preferred at high pH, where their chelating efficacy is particularly strong. This category includes sodium tripolyphosphate (STPP, Na5P3O10), tetrasodium pyrophosphate (TSPP, Na4P2O7), tetrapotassium pyrophosphate (TKPP) — whose potassium salts exhibit higher solubility than the sodium counterparts, making them advantageous for liquid formulations — and sodium hexametaphosphate (STMP, NaPO3)n.
Even auxiliaries with relatively weak chelating ability are not without drawbacks. For example, polycarboxylates—due to the so‑called polyelectrolyte effect—exhibit a chelating capacity (CCC) that increases with polymer molecular weight, reaching a maximum at around 10,000 g/mol. In this regard, the charge density of the polymer backbone is paramount; thus, taking BASF’s Sokalan CP‑7 as an example, it requires a high content of maleic acid (or fumaric acid) or a 50/50 acrylic/maleic copolymer with a molecular weight of approximately 50,000, whose complexation constant is roughly ten times that of comparable polyacrylates. However, polycarboxylates such as CP‑7 interact strongly with calcium ions and tend to precipitate under high hardness conditions, leading to a glassy‑looking surface on dishes. Moreover, even the strongest chelating polycarboxylates fall short of the performance of precipitating agents like carbonates. Consequently, in waters with high carbonate hardness, calcium carbonate forms before calcium ions can bind to the polymer. Fortunately, polycarboxylates serve as effective inhibitors of crystal growth, preventing scale from depositing on tableware. Yet, while low‑molecular‑weight polymers favor crystal‑growth inhibition, robust chelation requires high molecular weights, necessitating a pronounced bimodal chain‑length distribution. The need for long chains to achieve effective chelation represents another drawback of polyacrylates: their biodegradability. When the polymer is synthesized to a chain length sufficient for chelation, the most efficient acrylic and maleic monomers often prove non‑biodegradable. Attempts to construct block copolymers using biodegradable comonomers—such as vinyl alcohol—typically result in polymers that either contain excessive vinyl alcohol, compromising chelating efficacy, or too much acrylic/maleic acid, rendering them non‑biodegradable. For these reasons, polycarboxylates are commonly employed in dishwashing detergents as co‑builders or simply as scale inhibitors.
In a phosphate-free formulation, when the wash liquor’s pH decreases, trisodium citrate is currently the preferred builder, as its masking capacity is relatively insensitive to pH changes. Citrates are safe, biodegradable builders derived from sugar fermentation. Their main drawbacks are high cost and moderate masking performance. Moreover, the relatively weak masking ability of citrates necessitates the inclusion of an effective bleaching agent to prevent the buildup of tea stains.