Common components of dishwasher detergent formulations
Nov 19,2021
Based on their functions in detergents, these components are classified as follows: builders, auxiliaries, scale inhibitors, bleaching agents, enzymes, spot/film control agents, and antifoams. In addition to their individual forms and roles, these components interact with one another and depend on each other.
Buffer
Buffering agents are used to increase the alkalinity of the washing solution; it is well known that high-pH formulations offer widespread advantages in soil removal.
In earlier reviews, a formulation with a pH of 11.1 was compared to one with a pH of 9.8. The lower-pH formulation—comprising boiled eggs, cereals, milk, and margarine—proved less effective at removing laboratory soil. It has been demonstrated that higher detergent pH levels are highly effective at swelling soils, thereby facilitating their removal. Taking pre‑cooked starch gels as an example, the swelling ratio in alkaline buffer solutions was examined at 50°C as a function of pH. The results showed that, as the buffer pH increased from 8 to 12, the starch swelled moderately and exhibited an increasing trend. This phenomenon also applies to protein hydrolysis and the subsequent removal of egg‑based soils. At elevated pH values, both types of soil become partially ionized, and the repulsive forces between like‑charged groups within the soil significantly reduce its cohesive strength. Moreover, since both glass/ceramic substrates and the soils themselves carry negative charges at high pH, the adhesion of the soils to the substrate is further diminished. Tea stains, particularly when they accumulate, likewise pose little problem at higher pH levels. The polyphenolic chromophores in tea stains are thought to undergo deprotonation, thereby reducing the soil’s adhesion and cohesion. On the downside, alkaline pH can lead to degradation of certain materials, such as discoloration.
Effective buffering agents in dishwasher detergents include sodium hydroxide, sodium carbonate, and various silicates. For certain silicates, 1% solutions of these bases have pH values of 13.1, 11.4, and 12.3 at 20 °C, respectively. Phosphates, which are primarily used as builders, also contribute to alkaline buffering. Despite concerns about the formation of a water film by soda ash (sodium carbonate), it remains a common ingredient in dishwasher detergents due to its low cost and widespread availability. Carbonates, silicates, other alkaline agents, and their mixtures offer multiple ways to raise the pH of the wash solution.
A pH between 11 and 12 is conducive to cleaning; however, in recent years, most advances in the machine‑dishwashing field have aimed at lowering the detergent’s pH to reduce environmental impact and minimize human exposure risks. Ideally, while ensuring compatibility with enzyme stability, bleach performance, and health and environmental considerations, one should select the highest feasible pH to maximize the benefits of alkaline mechanisms—though this typically brings the detergent’s pH down to around 10. Within this range, deprotonation of soil still offers some advantage for removing egg‑based (protein) soils, but the majority of soil removal relies on enzymatic action. Nevertheless, a reduction of about one pH unit has been shown to be costly when tackling stubborn tea stains. A decline in the degree of soil deprotonation implies that extremely low levels of free calcium ions are required to maintain low soil cohesion and adhesion. Calcium‑sequestering agents are primarily deprotonating acids, so they begin to lose effectiveness at lower pH values. Consequently, when formulating at reduced pHs, formulators must balance several competing trends.
For dishwasher detergents, the reserve alkalinity of phosphates, silicates, and sodium hydroxide exceeds 6.2%. Alkaline silicates serve as a key alkaline buffer in dishwasher detergents, including highly corrosive sodium metasilicate (Na2SiO3·nH2O).